The Death of Lucano: a novella by
Alberto Moravia (Racconti Surrealistici e Satirici)
Morte di Lucano: una novella di Alberto
Moravia
When Lucano learned that they would
have spared his life if he had consented to reveal the names of his
accomplices in the Pisone conspiracy, the air of conventional and
rhetorical stoicism that he had assumed since the beginning of the
trial fell off him like oversized clothes, and he felt pervaded by a
morbid and agitated disquiet. In his original desperation he had
considered everything: the proud answers he would give the judges,
the noble dignity he would retain during the trial, the verses he
would recite at the point of death, his premature end framed by an
aureola of fame, strength and virtue, his contemporaries and
descendants. In his vain agony, he had considered everything short of
being able, at the price of cowardice, to save his life. He had gone
to great lengths to alleviate and adorn this death, which he had
thought fatal, with all the frills of rhetoric of which he was a
master. And in the submission forced onto him, these frills seemed to
him like memorable gestures and laments torn away from his soul by
the extreme danger threatening him. Yet now, that same death that he
could not help disguise and mask in the latest fashion, appeared to
him almost as a safe refuge, a warm comfortable den, compared to the
doubt that the judges' promise had instilled in him; he was no longer
consoled by the vainly sweet rhetorical image of a valiant death.
During those dark and grievous days following the discovery of the
conspiracy, he had already seen himself outside his life, in a grey
and mournful zone, amidst those shadows whose example he was thinking
of following. But now the wicked and calculated promise of the
judges, along with his hope and desire to live, gave him back a
burden heavier than life itself – that of conscience having to
deliberate upon which conduct to follow. During that night of death,
from which the judges' promise would take him away, there was nothing
but horror; but now, the new dawn that seemed to rise for him
contained an even greater horror: the requirement, perfectly new for
him, to act no longer as a courtier whose manifold talents were
admired and praised everywhere, but as a man. He was asked to choose
in such conditions where he could not be assisted by his many natural
gifts, and without a distinction being made between him, who had
almost facetiously taken part in the conspiracy, and his companions
who had plotted it and would have gained the princedom had it been
successful. His easy, fatuous and vain life found him unprepared for
such a lack of choice, and embittered by the unfairness of his
destiny, Lucano felt almost unable to mentally capture the
seriousness and importance of the dilemma he had been presented with.
And instead of real people and facts he saw rhetorical shadows as far
from him as Caesar, Brutus and the ghosts of Pompei evoked in the
Pharsalia. My mother, my friends – he kept saying to himself; but
his mother and his friends remained pale and still, and their
worthiness was difficult to determine outside a world full of those
declaimed and rigid moral rules from which he had taken his
characters. Betraying one's friends, one's mother, he thought, is a
base shameful action. But in what world were these actions base and
shameful? In that where he had lived so far, or in the theatrical one
of Uncle Seneca's plays? In reality, he no longer saw the meaning of
this unworthiness; in committing it, he didn't know what he would
have lost, but only what he would have gained. He felt fake and
conventional when facing the duty that was hanging over him; real and
humane when considering the prize he would have gained by failing to
fulfill this duty. In front of his mother and his friends was the
stoic character of a tragedy, standing draped in his toga, the arm
stretched, the mouth open pleading; however, in front of the life he
would obtain in exchange for his betrayal, it was him, Lucano. That
Lucano with his hair tousled by horror, without any tears left to cry
nor voice to scream, soiled and ragged from so much struggling; that
Lucano who was frightened and did not want to die. “Timorum
maximum” - that is what he had called the fear of death in the
Pharsalia. And was it perhaps due to this fear that, in front of the
pallour and coldness of his mother and his friends, life was in his
eyes so colourful and gracious? Firstly the sun, the sweet sun,
scorching in the summer, tired and red in the autumn, merry in the
spring, grateful in the cold winters, was waiting for him outside the
prison, offering him, who had reported his own mother, the same light
as to the noblest of men. The land would have smiled at him too, with
its rivers meandering through the blue mountains and flowing into the
sea, its forests full of birds and docile beasts, and its vast sky
where winds were moving the clouds. He would have still walked this
land, if he had lived. But even sweeter than sun and earth, a
sufficient enough reason for living even for men with no honour, was
to him the charming and greedy profession of man of letters. Who, he
thought, would not commit the worst of betrayals knowing with
certainty that he would then write a poem, beautiful and perfect like
Homer's? Or fantasy of heroes, battles, gods, marvels, choose words
from the profoundness of an inspired mind, put them carefully
together in long phrases, read with insight, discuss with sharpness,
and endlessly meditate; and then declaim, win the applause, listen to
praise and criticism, see his name spread – what more on earth
could anyone want? Surely not the sterile and dusty fame of stoic
virtue; as a single verse of Virgil was worth more than all of Cato's
intrepid obstinacy. Now Lucano was only twenty-seven and he thought
that if he were to live, he would be capable of writing things more
beautiful than Virgil's; things that, he was trying to convince
himself, would more than justify any betrayal. Victim of an agitated
disquiet and with these thoughts in his mind, Lucano spent that day.
And in the evening, the judges came back to interrogate him:
“Atilia”, he said, “my mother Atilia is amongst the accomplices
of Pisone”. One of the judges was sitting and writing, the second
was interrogating him and the third carried a sword in his hand. And
the one with the sword, no sooner had Lucano reported his mother and
friends, said to Lucano who was anxiously looking at him: “The
promise will not be kept. You must die”. At these words Lucano,
realizing he had lost at once his reputation, his mother and his
life, threw himself to the ground imploring and screaming. But the
judges were already walking away, outside the closed door and along
the corridors. The following day, reciting some of his verses about a
dying soldier, Lucano held out his wrists to the surgeon. At
twenty-seven, while the sun continued to shine and the celestial
bodies turned in a perpetual movement, he knew he was dying for
futile reasons, for cowardice that no poetic dignity could ever
redeem. Who would henceforth talk about him? Grammarians and
rhetoricians. Having recited the first verses, he looked at the blood
flowing out of the large veins on his wrists and with thinner
streams, like some kind of malignant root, coating his ten fingers
spread and dangling up to his nails. In spite of his continual
recitation, he knew that there was no remedy to those open, broken
veins, and that the blood dripping from his fingers would not go back
into the veins; and his voice trembled and grew into a liquid and
vast affliction. Look, he wanted to scream, look at how I die. But
death was already being described in his verses, nor was there time.
Thus, once his brief song finished, his life faded away.
- The end -
This was a very interesting short-story. Moravia raises many good points about how to act faced with such a tremendous situation, and he describes the protagonist's mind with so much sensibility. I never read Moravia but The Conformist is a novel I want to read one day because of the movie.
ReplyDeleteYour translation is also very good, it's fluid and uses excellent vocabulary. Are you a professional translator?
Thank you very much, Miguel.
DeleteI am a professional translator, but not in the field of literature. I read and translate literature in my free time.
I translated another short story by Moravia and will post it shortly.
I also like Moravia for his sensibility and honesty in describing human nature.
Unfortunately, I am not familiar with Il Conformista.